SWF Flash Maps

Are Flash (SWF) maps worthwhile, or just a gimmick?

Many sites have been putting up some pretty slick SWF maps lately, and the big map api’s (google, yahoo, mapquest — ve?) have followed suite. There’s obviously something cool about these SWF maps. However, when I tried to figure out if it would be worth creating one for the most recent CML application, I was hard pressed to figure out how to make a flash map do what I want it to to do, and would it be worth it.

The reason flash maps are compelling: they’re vectorized and all geometries are fully loaded after the flash is loaded. This allows all sorts of interaction with individual elements — elements which don’t need to be pulled from remote store. Yet, a prime concern also seems to be more control over styling, and quick integration with other adobe cs tools.

but for a site which needs to generate vectors on the fly from a spatial database, which would then be loaded into the map, is flash still worthwhile? the speed of static geometries would be sacrificed, much of the non-map ui enhancements done in flash can be replicated by using scriptaculus. Other features must be considered.

Especially consider the NYC Subway map — very nice — if I can get something like this working, it would be well worth doing in flash — still though, none of these geographies are generated on the fly, so something involving the database/data and xml is probably necessary.

Check out these links:
http://www.onnyturf.com/subway/

Google Maps Collaboration using Flex, Flash Media Server and Ajax (Updated for Flex 2 GA)


http://justin.everett-church.com/index.php/2005/11/08/maps-that-are-consistent-with-your-design/
http://developer.yahoo.com/flash/maps/
http://map.uoregon.edu/
http://www.theweathernetwork.com/

Leave Comment